I sent an email today


Leah Rowe

Return to index

Article published by: GNU Leah Rowe

Date of publication: 17 November 2026

I sent an email today. For GDPR reasons I can’t show who I BCC’d to, but I sent it generally to:

I intended for the email to be public, hence such an exhaustive list; I also copied and pasted it on IRC. Because the email is personal, ostensibly about my projects but otherwise of a human nature, I won’t publish it on the Libreboot news blog. Instead, I publish it here on my personal blog.

It is the uncensored version of what I published here:

https://libreboot.org/news/chrultrabook.html

The email was intended to de-escalate some drama that happened privately, and then publicly - by keeping it public, and keeping myself accountable, I therefore hold myself to account, as can others. It signals my good will towards a specific group of people in the Free Software movement, who otherwise ignored all attempts to do this privately. I found their ignoring of my advances insulting - and expected that another attempt would also be ignored.

Not everyone will like you. That’s just life, but I am not to be ignored.

The email is thus:

To the Chrultrabook community:

I would like to extend my thanks, to you and to intersecting projects like
MrChromebox and Nura, the culmination of which have led to a revolution in the
Free Software movement in the past few years. Your extensive work reverse
engineering hardware and making it all boot with Free Software is extremely
understated in the wider Free Software movement, and I have made it my mission
to ensure that you are recognised. For my part, I have therefore written the
following article on my Libreboot website:

https://libreboot.org/news/chrultrabook.html

The context is that Libreboot, my free and opensource UEFI firmware project,
recently imported hundreds of Chromebooks from the MrChromebox project whose
developer Matt DeVillier, and those who work on Chrultrabook, have been
invaluable.

That's all I wanted to say: thank you.

I also made sure to prominently give thanks publicly, in the following places:

https://mas.to/@libreleah/117632686942173585

https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/1xymjin/libreboot_thank_you_chrultrabook_and_mrchromebox/

https://www.reddit.com/r/coreboot/comments/1xymiz4/libreboot_thank_you_chrultrabook_and_mrchromebox/

The public posts are more brief, and mostly expressing gratitude. This email
will now go into some depth about a schism that had previously developed,
leading to an initial hostility, a boiling of blood on my part, and then finally
- today - an epiphany on my part.

I was motivated on a personal and moral level to write the article. I announced
the intention to integrate support for Google Chromebook hardware in Libreboot
during 2025, and it sparked quite a bit of private controversy at the time. I
wrote this post, in 2025:

https://mas.to/@libreleah/115331017789075262

This post contained a calling for hardware donations; it was misunderstood and
one of Chrultrabook's developers, sdomi, expressed disbelief that I seemed to be
monetising the work; I had no such intention, I do actually have a company that
does coreboot things but it's not very big nor do I want it to be. People send
me hardware every now and then to work on, and I even stopped selling computers
recently - because I want more time to hack on code. I still do send-ins, but I
basically hate corporate/politics. All I want is to hack on projects.

Anyway, sdomi's concerns were valid, because she and others in Chrultrabook did
a lot of the hard work over the years to reverse engineer and clean up Google's
code, upstreaming everything and making everything work smoothly so that these
devices are meaningfully friendly for people who want Free Software on their
computers. Their work has gone largely underappreciated over the years, and they
face the brunt of the wrath that is user support requests, many of them
non-technical Windows users who can't follow simple instructions. They do it for
fun, out of pocket and on their own time - and the work is very stressful.
Burnout is common for such projects, and they deal extensively with largely
uncooperative corporations (including Google) who, despite rhetoric, are
actually hostile - the real work to make these devices truly open source is done
in large part by the Chrultrabook project.

It wasn't just sdomi. I learned that this fear was common amongst the developers
in Chrultrabook. In response, I approached one of Chrultrabook's lead
developers, Alicja Michalska (ellyq) at 39c3 conference in Hamburg, as I was
also going, and just happened to spot her sitting at a table. I was largely
ignored - she did not engage meaningfully with me in any way. I'd tried emailing
her and others in and around the project, including Matt DeVillier of
MrChromebox with whom I had contact, and whom gave me some valuable information
for future Libreboot work.

My purpose in such communications was to state precisely what's in the
now-public article, and to emphasise that I wish to work constructively with
them. I did not at any time want Libreboot to suck any of the energy out of the
room - I actually delayed adding Chromebooks to Libreboot because of all this
(added in October 2026 but originally planned for December 2025 / January 2026).

I contacted many people, trying to make peace. All for naught. I learned that
the schism was widening, not by my own will - I regarded them with the utmost
respect, and I still do, hence the article. After my FOSDEM talk about Libreboot
in January 2026, when I again announced the Chromebook integration plan, I was
approached by someone who wanted to do some upstream coreboot development work,
and they approached me asking about the situation. They had contacted the
Chrultrabook project first, and they were deciding whether to work with them or
with me - because ellyq had stated vaguely that she was pissed off at me - for
all of these and other reasons. She and others in that project believed that I
was basically just going to take credit for all the work, and cause problems for
them; a valid concern, given Libreboot's reach, and such a concern may be
realised if I were to handle it irresponsibly. In that instance, I told the
individual to work with Chrultrabook because they are much closer to upstream.
My own work is simply integration - I integrate and package coreboot, like how
Debian does linux packages basically.

Nothing for months, then finally recently I did the Libreboot releases, with all
of the Chromebooks integrated. I made several technical decisions that ellyq
disagreed with, violently, such as the decision to disable the Intel Management
Engine by default - to which she objected, calling me hostile or incompetent (on
Mastodon), because doing so would break DSP signature verification on various
audio chipsets used in Chromebooks, not to mention other issues. I didn't know
this, but did revert the decision - I also implemented a suggestion by her and
others to ensure that Libreboot can be identified in upstream bug reports, for
example writing Libreboot in coreboot logs at startup and stating the version,
ditto writing "libreboot" in dmi strings. This is to reduce the extra
anticipated burden as a result of many new Libreboot users who may otherwise
erroneously report Libreboot bugs upstream.

I won't keep going on technical ramblings. Basically, I sensed for some time
that there was some bad blood.

That's all there is. I was getting angry on IRC recently because basically I
thought that the Chrultrabook developers were hostile to Libreboot and had some
sort of vague agenda against it. Really stupid. I snapped out of it and wrote
the article instead. Anything other than good will and cooperation on my part -
where it is wanted - would be folly. I will otherwise disengage.

The kind of statements and general substance of the article are essentially that
of what I tried to communicate a year ago in private, but with one difference
now:

I no longer require the Chrultrabook to like me personally, or my work - I also
do not require an apology from them for actual injustices that they may have
subjected me to. No, I decided that I would rather de-escalate.

The other difference is that I tried to be nice in private: trying to establish
peace by preventing hostility from spilling out in public. But elly for example
willingly and openly attacked me on my Mastodon thread when I announced
Libreboot 26.10, criticising me for decisions and accusing me of hostility
without having spoken to me first, perhaps because I was not considered worthy
to talk to:

https://mas.to/@libreleah/117443669302441681

It's all just a complete misunderstanding. While I myself may have overreacted
at first, I don't actually have any hostile plans - despite what some ramblings
on IRC may have otherwise suggested. I articulated, at several points and on
several different days, actively hostile intentions towards specific people, but
I rescind all such intent. I was angry because I accurately perceived myself to
be under attack. After the dealings on Mastodon, and as a result of insecurities
on my part, I basically went completely overboard for a brief period, entirely
on IRC (in the libreboot chatroom in fact), because I believed that I would be
under further attack. To worry about such things is futile, but worry I did.
That accuracy is otherwise irrelevant; it is entirely and completely irrelevant.
What matters is the work. Anything that helps the work will be done as much as
possible - anything that is a liability, such as petty irrelevant drama, will be
avoided.

I concluded that any negative feeling about me on their part won't change, and
making it any worse would be pointless, so I hereby rescind all of it and I will
simply go back to my original position: respect the work, respect the upstream,
credit the authors, thank the authors. Hence the article. Any feelings I had
recently as a result of this escalating drama are entirely irrelevant, and I
have chosen to disregard them entirely, even if I may have felt justified.

My policy is simply to focus on Libreboot, and to be as unobstructive as
possible to the work of others. Thus have I begun promoting their work and
crediting it more prominently - whether they like it or not, I did then and
still do now greatly respect these people and their works. I wish for it to
continue, and I will do everything in my power to help, in whatever way I can.
Even if they do not wish to work with me directly, which I respect too - yes.
Elly herself rejected the notion, saying that she does not need my help - and so
she will not receive it. Help given where help is wanted. I do not wish to
impose on anyone.

A truce. I have decided unilaterally to be nice to these people at all times,
and to respect them greatly, and to focus relentlessly on my own work without
regard for drama. I will do this, and I expect nothing in return. I do not
expect cooperation, and I do not demand respect. They can think whatever they
wish about me, and I will just keep doing Libreboot releases - and I will
regularly promote them, whenever indicated. For example, if they're working on
something really cool.

The article was written because it's the right thing to do. It simply provides
the thanks and the recognition that this monumental series of works deserve -
the Chrultrabook and MrChromebox projects have done what very few people could,
and our entire movement, that of the Free Software movement, would be in much
worse shape without them. This is simply a fact, and so I thank them greatly.

I require neither a response nor even an acknowledgement that this email has
even been read. Any hostile statements made by myself or others, feelings one
way or the other, and indeed actions that may have been taken, are now entirely
irrelevant. I have put them out of my mind, and this email shall serve as
closure.

Good day.

Markdown file for this page: https://vimuser.org/email.md

Site map

This HTML page was generated by the Libreboot Static Site Generator.